add field-level change details to dry-run and reconcile output

This commit is contained in:
Prox 2026-03-06 19:11:36 +02:00
parent 490ae09a3f
commit ad8557d543
5 changed files with 199 additions and 51 deletions

View File

@ -87,16 +87,59 @@ jobs:
elif t.startswith("delete"): groups["Delete"].append(op)
else: groups["Update"].append(op)
def fmt_val(v):
"""Format a value for display in markdown."""
if isinstance(v, bool):
return str(v).lower()
if isinstance(v, list):
return ", ".join(str(x) for x in v) if v else "(empty)"
if v is None:
return "(none)"
return str(v)
def fmt_create_details(op):
"""Summarize key fields for a create operation."""
d = op.get("details", {})
if not d:
return ""
parts = []
if "enabled" in d:
parts.append(f"enabled={fmt_val(d['enabled'])}")
if "sources" in d and "destinations" in d:
parts.append(f"{fmt_val(d['sources'])} → {fmt_val(d['destinations'])}")
if "auto_groups" in d:
parts.append(f"groups: {fmt_val(d['auto_groups'])}")
if "type" in d and "address" in d:
parts.append(f"{d['type']}:{d['address']}")
if "peers" in d:
parts.append(f"peers: {fmt_val(d['peers'])}")
return "; ".join(parts) if parts else ""
def fmt_changes(op):
"""Format field changes as 'field: old → new'."""
changes = op.get("changes", [])
if not changes:
return ""
parts = []
for c in changes:
parts.append(f"`{c['field']}`: {fmt_val(c['from'])} → {fmt_val(c['to'])}")
return "; ".join(parts)
for action, items in groups.items():
if not items:
continue
emoji = {"Create": "+", "Update": "~", "Delete": "-"}[action]
lines.append(f"### {action} ({len(items)})\n")
lines.append("| Resource | Name |")
lines.append("|----------|------|")
lines.append("| Resource | Name | Details |")
lines.append("|----------|------|---------|")
for op in items:
resource = op["type"].split("_", 1)[1] if "_" in op["type"] else op["type"]
lines.append(f"| {resource} | {op['name']} |")
if action == "Update":
detail = fmt_changes(op)
elif action == "Create":
detail = fmt_create_details(op)
else:
detail = ""
lines.append(f"| {resource} | {op['name']} | {detail} |")
lines.append("")
c, u, d = summary.get("created", 0), summary.get("updated", 0), summary.get("deleted", 0)

View File

@ -95,6 +95,27 @@ jobs:
f"{summary.get('updated',0)} updated, "
f"{summary.get('deleted',0)} deleted")
# Log each operation with details
for op in data.get("operations", []):
t = op["type"]
n = op["name"]
s = op.get("status", "?")
action = "CREATE" if t.startswith("create") else "DELETE" if t.startswith("delete") else "UPDATE"
resource = t.split("_", 1)[1] if "_" in t else t
prefix = f"[{env}] {action} {resource} '{n}' -> {s}"
changes = op.get("changes", [])
if changes:
def fmt(v):
if isinstance(v, bool): return str(v).lower()
if isinstance(v, list): return ", ".join(str(x) for x in v) if v else "(empty)"
if v is None: return "(none)"
return str(v)
parts = [f"{c['field']}: {fmt(c['from'])} -> {fmt(c['to'])}" for c in changes]
print(f" {prefix} [{'; '.join(parts)}]")
else:
print(f" {prefix}")
keys = data.get("created_keys", {})
if keys:
print(f"[{env}] Created setup keys: {list(keys.keys())}")

View File

@ -1,7 +1,11 @@
import type { DesiredState } from "../state/schema.ts";
import type { ActualState } from "../state/actual.ts";
import type { NbPolicyRule } from "../netbird/types.ts";
import { EXECUTION_ORDER, type Operation } from "./operations.ts";
import {
EXECUTION_ORDER,
type FieldChange,
type Operation,
} from "./operations.ts";
/**
* Compares desired state against actual state and returns an ordered list of
@ -53,10 +57,14 @@ function diffPostureChecks(
continue;
}
if (
existing.description !== config.description ||
JSON.stringify(existing.checks) !== JSON.stringify(config.checks)
) {
const pcChanges: FieldChange[] = [];
if (existing.description !== config.description) {
pcChanges.push({ field: "description", from: existing.description, to: config.description });
}
if (JSON.stringify(existing.checks) !== JSON.stringify(config.checks)) {
pcChanges.push({ field: "checks", from: existing.checks, to: config.checks });
}
if (pcChanges.length > 0) {
ops.push({
type: "update_posture_check",
name,
@ -64,6 +72,7 @@ function diffPostureChecks(
description: config.description,
checks: config.checks,
},
changes: pcChanges,
});
}
}
@ -108,6 +117,9 @@ function diffGroups(
desired_peers: desiredPeerNames,
actual_peers: actualPeerNames,
},
changes: [
{ field: "peers", from: actualPeerNames, to: desiredPeerNames },
],
});
}
}
@ -219,6 +231,9 @@ function diffNetworks(
type: "update_network",
name,
details: { description: config.description },
changes: [
{ field: "description", from: existing.description, to: config.description },
],
});
}
@ -293,13 +308,23 @@ function diffNetworkResources(
const actualGroupNames = existing.groups.map((g) => g.name).sort();
const desiredGroupNames = [...res.groups].sort();
if (
existing.description !== res.description ||
existing.type !== res.type ||
existing.address !== res.address ||
existing.enabled !== res.enabled ||
!arraysEqual(actualGroupNames, desiredGroupNames)
) {
const resChanges: FieldChange[] = [];
if (existing.description !== res.description) {
resChanges.push({ field: "description", from: existing.description, to: res.description });
}
if (existing.type !== res.type) {
resChanges.push({ field: "type", from: existing.type, to: res.type });
}
if (existing.address !== res.address) {
resChanges.push({ field: "address", from: existing.address, to: res.address });
}
if (existing.enabled !== res.enabled) {
resChanges.push({ field: "enabled", from: existing.enabled, to: res.enabled });
}
if (!arraysEqual(actualGroupNames, desiredGroupNames)) {
resChanges.push({ field: "groups", from: actualGroupNames, to: desiredGroupNames });
}
if (resChanges.length > 0) {
ops.push({
type: "update_network_resource",
name: res.name,
@ -312,6 +337,7 @@ function diffNetworkResources(
enabled: res.enabled,
groups: res.groups,
},
changes: resChanges,
});
}
}
@ -362,11 +388,17 @@ function diffNetworkRouters(
}
// Compare mutable fields
if (
existing.metric !== router.metric ||
existing.masquerade !== router.masquerade ||
existing.enabled !== router.enabled
) {
const routerChanges: FieldChange[] = [];
if (existing.metric !== router.metric) {
routerChanges.push({ field: "metric", from: existing.metric, to: router.metric });
}
if (existing.masquerade !== router.masquerade) {
routerChanges.push({ field: "masquerade", from: existing.masquerade, to: router.masquerade });
}
if (existing.enabled !== router.enabled) {
routerChanges.push({ field: "enabled", from: existing.enabled, to: router.enabled });
}
if (routerChanges.length > 0) {
ops.push({
type: "update_network_router",
name: key,
@ -379,6 +411,7 @@ function diffNetworkRouters(
masquerade: router.masquerade,
enabled: router.enabled,
},
changes: routerChanges,
});
}
}
@ -441,7 +474,7 @@ function diffPeers(
const existing = actual.peersByName.get(name);
if (!existing) continue; // Never create or delete peers
let changed = false;
const peerChanges: FieldChange[] = [];
// Compare groups (excluding "All"), resolve actual peer group names
const actualGroupNames = existing.groups
@ -450,19 +483,20 @@ function diffPeers(
.sort();
const desiredGroupNames = [...config.groups].sort();
if (!arraysEqual(actualGroupNames, desiredGroupNames)) {
changed = true;
peerChanges.push({ field: "groups", from: actualGroupNames, to: desiredGroupNames });
}
if (
existing.login_expiration_enabled !== config.login_expiration_enabled ||
existing.inactivity_expiration_enabled !==
config.inactivity_expiration_enabled ||
existing.ssh_enabled !== config.ssh_enabled
) {
changed = true;
if (existing.login_expiration_enabled !== config.login_expiration_enabled) {
peerChanges.push({ field: "login_expiration_enabled", from: existing.login_expiration_enabled, to: config.login_expiration_enabled });
}
if (existing.inactivity_expiration_enabled !== config.inactivity_expiration_enabled) {
peerChanges.push({ field: "inactivity_expiration_enabled", from: existing.inactivity_expiration_enabled, to: config.inactivity_expiration_enabled });
}
if (existing.ssh_enabled !== config.ssh_enabled) {
peerChanges.push({ field: "ssh_enabled", from: existing.ssh_enabled, to: config.ssh_enabled });
}
if (changed) {
if (peerChanges.length > 0) {
ops.push({
type: "update_peer",
name,
@ -472,6 +506,7 @@ function diffPeers(
inactivity_expiration_enabled: config.inactivity_expiration_enabled,
ssh_enabled: config.ssh_enabled,
},
changes: peerChanges,
});
}
}
@ -511,10 +546,14 @@ function diffUsers(
).sort();
const desiredAutoGroupNames = [...config.auto_groups].sort();
if (
existing.role !== config.role ||
!arraysEqual(actualAutoGroupNames, desiredAutoGroupNames)
) {
const userChanges: FieldChange[] = [];
if (existing.role !== config.role) {
userChanges.push({ field: "role", from: existing.role, to: config.role });
}
if (!arraysEqual(actualAutoGroupNames, desiredAutoGroupNames)) {
userChanges.push({ field: "auto_groups", from: actualAutoGroupNames, to: desiredAutoGroupNames });
}
if (userChanges.length > 0) {
ops.push({
type: "update_user",
name: email,
@ -523,6 +562,7 @@ function diffUsers(
role: config.role,
auto_groups: config.auto_groups,
},
changes: userChanges,
});
}
}
@ -609,12 +649,30 @@ function diffPolicies(
desiredPostureChecks,
);
if (
existing.enabled !== config.enabled ||
!arraysEqual(actualSources, desiredSources) ||
destsChanged ||
postureChecksChanged
) {
const changes: FieldChange[] = [];
if (existing.enabled !== config.enabled) {
changes.push({ field: "enabled", from: existing.enabled, to: config.enabled });
}
if (!arraysEqual(actualSources, desiredSources)) {
changes.push({ field: "sources", from: actualSources, to: desiredSources });
}
if (destsChanged) {
if (config.destination_resource) {
const actualDestRes = existing.rules[0]?.destinationResource;
changes.push({ field: "destination_resource", from: actualDestRes ?? null, to: config.destination_resource });
} else {
const actualDests = extractGroupNames(
existing.rules.flatMap((r) => r.destinations ?? []),
actual,
).sort();
changes.push({ field: "destinations", from: actualDests, to: [...config.destinations].sort() });
}
}
if (postureChecksChanged) {
changes.push({ field: "source_posture_checks", from: actualPostureChecks, to: desiredPostureChecks });
}
if (changes.length > 0) {
ops.push({
type: "update_policy",
name,
@ -625,6 +683,7 @@ function diffPolicies(
destination_resource: config.destination_resource,
source_posture_checks: config.source_posture_checks,
},
changes,
});
}
}
@ -682,11 +741,17 @@ function diffRoutes(
continue;
}
if (
existing.enabled !== config.enabled ||
existing.description !== config.description ||
existing.network !== config.network
) {
const routeChanges: FieldChange[] = [];
if (existing.enabled !== config.enabled) {
routeChanges.push({ field: "enabled", from: existing.enabled, to: config.enabled });
}
if (existing.description !== config.description) {
routeChanges.push({ field: "description", from: existing.description, to: config.description });
}
if (existing.network !== config.network) {
routeChanges.push({ field: "network", from: existing.network, to: config.network });
}
if (routeChanges.length > 0) {
ops.push({
type: "update_route",
name: networkId,
@ -695,6 +760,7 @@ function diffRoutes(
description: config.description,
network: config.network,
},
changes: routeChanges,
});
}
}
@ -741,11 +807,17 @@ function diffDns(
config.nameservers,
);
if (
existing.enabled !== config.enabled ||
existing.primary !== config.primary ||
nsChanged
) {
const dnsChanges: FieldChange[] = [];
if (existing.enabled !== config.enabled) {
dnsChanges.push({ field: "enabled", from: existing.enabled, to: config.enabled });
}
if (existing.primary !== config.primary) {
dnsChanges.push({ field: "primary", from: existing.primary, to: config.primary });
}
if (nsChanged) {
dnsChanges.push({ field: "nameservers", from: existing.nameservers, to: config.nameservers });
}
if (dnsChanges.length > 0) {
ops.push({
type: "update_dns",
name,
@ -754,6 +826,7 @@ function diffDns(
primary: config.primary,
nameservers: config.nameservers,
},
changes: dnsChanges,
});
}
}

View File

@ -33,10 +33,17 @@ export type OperationType =
| "update_user"
| "delete_user";
export interface FieldChange {
field: string;
from: unknown;
to: unknown;
}
export interface Operation {
type: OperationType;
name: string;
details?: Record<string, unknown>;
changes?: FieldChange[];
}
export interface OperationResult extends Operation {

View File

@ -109,6 +109,8 @@ async function handleReconcile(
operations: ops.map((op) => ({
type: op.type,
name: op.name,
...(op.details && { details: op.details }),
...(op.changes && { changes: op.changes }),
})),
summary: summarize(ops),
});
@ -141,6 +143,8 @@ async function handleReconcile(
type: r.type,
name: r.name,
status: r.status,
...(r.details && { details: r.details }),
...(r.changes && { changes: r.changes }),
})),
created_keys: createdKeysObj,
summary: summarize(results),